How to adapt Profit First for Insurance

The Profit First cash flow management system is a powerful tool for ensuring financial stability and profitability. However, to be truly effective for insurance agencies, it requires adjustments to account for the unique financial structure, start-up costs and revenue timelines.

Accounting for high upfront costs

Starting an agency requires significant initial investment – often exceeding $100,000.  Unlike many service-based businesses where the owner can operate solo, insurance agencies typically require at least one employee to maintain sales and customer services.

• Early commissions often do not cover fixed and variable costs in the first 2 years.

• The Profit First Allocations need to be adjusted to accommodate for these front-loaded expenses.

• A longer ramp-up period is needed before hitting the standard profit first allocation percentages.  

Managing the Three-Year-Ramp-Up period

Most insurance agents take at least three years to build enough residual income to cover monthly expenses. This means:

• Constant review and optimization of expenses are critical to improving margins.  

• Profit First must be an on-going process, not a “set it and forget it” system.

• The allocation percentages should evolve as the agency grows and revenue stabilizes.

New Market vs. Book of Business Considerations

The implementation of Profit First depends on whether an agent is:

A new market agent (start from scratch):

• Requires a much slower rollout of Profit First

• The initial allocation may be as low as 1% profit and 99% operations for 1 year.  

Agent Opening with Acquired book of business

• Can implement the system much faster since there’s existing cash flow.

• More stable revenue allows for higher allocations in profit, taxes and owners’ pay. 

Understanding this distinction makes certain Profit First is tailored to the unique financial situation. 

 Captive Agents: Optimizing Bonus Pay

Many captive agents receive bonuses from their carriers, which in turn are used to cover taxes. However, to build a sustainable and rewarding business:

• The bonus should primarily serve as owner’s pay, reflecting the risk taken in starting the business.

• Taxes should be set aside consistently throughout the year.

• Structuring the system this way ensures the agent is appropriately compensating themselves while maintaining financial stability.

Achieving Debt Freedom with Residual Income

By year 3, residual commissions should sustain the business, allowing a strategic approach to eliminating startup costs.

• A new Profit First allocation ought to be created to divert a portion of new business commissions to debt repayment.

• With careful planning and an attitude of patience, the business becomes debt-free faster.

• Once debt-free, the agency can redirect cash into reserves, growth and personal wealth.   

The benefits of a Profit First Insurance Agency

• Improved cash flow – no loan payments eating into profit.

• Less stress – greater financial predictability 

• Ability to pivot during down markets – More agility in turbulent times.

• Stronger reserves for emergencies – Be your own bank

• True financial freedom – The business supports the lifestyle the owner wants.

Take control of Your Agency’s Finances Today!

The insurance industry is changing drastically in front of our eyes, but your financial success doesn’t have to be uncertain. With the right Profit First strategy, you can stabilize cash flow, eliminate debt and build lasting wealth no matter where you are in your journey.

• Struggling with cash flow? We can customize your Profit First Journey

• Worried about covering expenses?  We can create a plan to optimize your costs.

• Want to become debt-free? We can create a debt repayment plan.

• Book a Discovery call today – Let’s transform your future.

  
  

Schedule Your Call Now!